How about ripped Blue Jeans??
I like them; they look tight! But I want to wear a pair NOW, not wait unitl I rip through the knees myself!
If playing a relic'd axe on stage imparts the vibe of years of road-work to the guy playing it, what's so bad about that?
I've owned (3) relics- A N**H; a Sand****, and a Danelectro (!!).
I liked them all because they played well, looks be damned. My '69P-Bass is pretty "relic'd" but its from the real deal.
Personally, I love the G&L output so much- ESPECIALLY the out-of-this world buids from the G&L CS I would always want the build I ordered to be pristine, and stay that way, especially with the incredible job the finish dept. does.
But to each their own, and the skillz needed to build a good relic job are massive.
That's my .02; I'll leave quietly now...
