Hi Bill,
Thanks for jumping in again.
While I'm convinced that ASAT's are a genuine improvement over Telecasters, I'm less convinced that G&L S-type guitars represent much improvement over a good Strat.
A case in point is my mid-90's S-500 which, if you look at the specs, promises much. The expander switch gives 2 extra pickup combinations. Cool. The MFD's are supposed to add extra body while retaining a certain strattiness. Excellent. Locking tuners as standard. Fantastic.
In reality it is stiff and heavy like Ken's returned ASAT. The small MFD's have no mojo either. I don't know if it's this particular guitar, or a property of the small MFD's in general. I really like the DF bridge on it, and the finish and appearance are top notch. The faux tele pickup combination is kinda cool, but I'm not in love with the PTB circuit. I can dial in plenty of different tones, but I don't like any of them much.
In the end I keep her 'cos she looks so purty. I keep meaning to experiment with different pickups and standard strat wiring, but for all the effort I should just move her on. Or hang her on the wall as decoration.
I'm never disappointed with my MIK Washburn J-9. It is a beautiful instrument. Since buying the J-9, Gibson 335's don't give me any GAS whatsover. My Tribute ASAT's are far better guitars than the purchase price would indicate too. And Jamie is spot on with the Maton electric guitars. Every one I've picked up has felt superb. Can't believe I don't own one. But there's still time.......