cmguitar wrote:1 So do you want to see G&L come back with a 3 Bolt neck? Even as a option.
Absolutely. It makes for a lot easier set-up, and I certainly cannot hear a difference between the 3-bolt and 4-bolt necks.
cmguitar wrote:#2 Do you feel the reissues are built better than the originals?
In most cases I would say yes. I would say that the Custom Shop Fenders are at least as good if not better. I had a 1960 vintage Strat, and the 1960 Strat relics feel pretty much dead on to me. Ditto for the Historic Les Pauls from Gibson. They seem to be very consistent, and I'm certainly happy with mine. Gretsch is a no brainer--some of the older Gretsches are real dogs--just kind of slapped together. They weren't very consistent with parts and specs, either. I think Martin is building some great guitars.
I think the big differences come down to wood and finishes. Obviously, a 2011 Martin D-28 with East Indian Rosewood and a Sitka top is not going to sound the same going out the factory door as a '50s Brazilian RW model with an Adirondack top. The ebony on the older guitar is going to be of better quality. Plus, the vintage guitar is going to be constructed with hide glue, not the modern adhesive. I think those are big differences. I think the quality of wood used back in the making of the older guitars was better. And it was certainly less expensive and more readily available.
The big guitar boom didn't really start until the late '50s. As production rose in the mid-'60s, quality went down. Fender, Gibson, Gretsch were all sold off to big companies looking make a profit from this exploding market. Even Martin nearly went under, but they hung on. Fender employees bought the company back and turned it around. Then you start seeing all the new builders: PRS, Larivee, Taylor, et. al. and the demand for tonewoods is at an all time high. And it is a limited resource.
Finishes have changed too. I think a lot of it is production costs, and warranty issues. It's cheaper and faster to apply a UV-cured poly finish than 18 thin coats of hand buffed NCL. The poly is pretty much impervious to anything you can throw at it, keeping the guitar newer looking longer. Same with the glue issue--a lot of folks think the hide-glued guitar is going to sound better, but it most certainly will need warranty work over a lifetime.
I think it is a tough job for manufacturers to improve their instrument, without losing the tone and feel of their vintage instruments. Of course they want to make more profit, and build things cheaper and faster. But this seems to be one business where, "New And Improved!!!" just doesn't cut it.
cmguitar wrote:#3 Are we tired of winter yet? Down under are we fed up with summer?
Yeah, but it is a really beautiful day here in Portland, Oregon. Clear, sunny and 47F. Oregon and Washington are known as the "Two-Season States".
Warm rain = summer. Cold rain = winter.
So true.
Bill